Can I Evict a Tenant Without a Tenancy Agreement?

A tenancy agreement outlines the rights and responsibilities of each party to a rental property, ensuring that both sides are protected and aware of their obligations. If you made a verbal agreement, lost the document, or your property is inherited property with sitting tenants, you may find various aspects of your obligations and rights confusing, particularly when it comes to eviction.

Regardless, a tenancy can exist without a formal agreement. However, proving the terms and conditions agreed upon can be challenging, making disputes more complicated to resolve.
In this blog post, we explain how to evict a tenant without a written tenancy agreement, guiding you through the laws and providing practical advice.

Instruct Us Our Approach

The legalities of eviction without a written tenancy agreement

Understanding the legal framework for the eviction process allows landlords to take the correct steps. For example, in the UK, verbal agreements can be legally binding. However, the lack of physical evidence can lead to disputes over the terms. When it comes to tenancy, rent payments and the landlord's acceptance thereof often serve as proof of the agreement, but the specifics (like the duration of tenancy and notice periods) can become points of contention.

The Housing Act 1988 outlines the rights and obligations of landlords and tenants, even in the absence of a written agreement. Most tenancies will automatically be considered an Assured Shorthold Tenancy (AST) under this act, granting tenants a degree of security and landlords the right to regain possession under certain conditions.

Landlords must serve an eviction notice to their tenants if they wish to end the tenancy. The type of notice can vary:

  • Section 21 Notice: used to end an AST at the end of its term.
  • Section 8 Notice: used if the tenant has breached the tenancy terms, such as not paying rent. Landlords must prove the terms were agreed upon.

Understanding these legal foundations is crucial before initiating the eviction process. They ensure that actions taken are within the law, protecting both the landlord's property rights and the tenant's rights to fair treatment.

The process of eviction without a written agreement

Evicting a tenant without a written tenancy agreement requires a careful and structured approach. Here's a step-by-step guide to the process.

  1. Establishing proof of tenancy: gather records of rent payments, communication between you and the tenant, and any other documentation that proves the existence of a landlord-tenant relationship. This evidence will be crucial in any legal proceedings.
  2. Serving notice: serve the appropriate notice to your tenant: with the Section 21 Notice or the Section 8 Notice, depending on the circumstances at hand. Remember, these notices must be served correctly, and the prescribed information must be provided to the tenant. Failure to do so can invalidate the eviction process.
  3. Court procedures: if the tenant does not leave by the specified date, you may need to file a claim for possession with the county court. Be prepared to present your evidence of the tenancy and any breach of terms. If the tenant still refuses to leave after a possession order is granted, you may need to use bailiffs to enforce the order. This is the legal way to ensure the tenant leaves the property.

Any misstep can delay the process or, worse, result in legal repercussions against you as the landlord, so you must seek the proper advice and guidance from tenancy advice experts such as those at AST Assistance.

Potential challenges of being a private landlord without a tenancy agreement

Evicting a tenant without a written agreement can present several challenges. Being aware of these potential issues and knowing how to address them can make the process smoother and more efficient.

  • Proving the terms of tenancy: without a written agreement, proving the terms of the tenancy (such as rent amount, payment dates, and responsibilities for repairs) can be difficult. Maintain thorough records of all communications with the tenant, receipts of rent payments, and any other interactions. This documentation can serve as evidence of the agreed terms.
  • Tenant disputes: tenants may dispute the eviction, especially if they claim the terms are different from what you assert or if they feel their rights are being violated. Ensure you follow the legal process meticulously. Provide all required notices and information to the tenant, and seek to resolve disputes through mediation if possible. If the case goes to court, present your evidence clearly and professionally.
  • Delays in the legal process: the court process can be lengthy, especially if the tenant contests the eviction. Delays can be costly and frustrating. While you cannot control the court's timeline, ensuring that all your documentation and evidence are in order and correctly submitted can help avoid unnecessary delays. Seeking legal advice from experts can ensure that you are taking the most efficient route possible.
  • Emotional and ethical considerations: evicting a tenant, especially one who may have been living in the property for a long time, can be an emotionally charged process. Approach the situation with empathy and professionalism. Ensure that all actions are legally justified and aim for a resolution that, as far as possible, respects the interests of both parties.

Best practices for landlords to avoid future complications

Prevention is always better than cure. To avoid the complexities of evicting a tenant without a written agreement, follow best practices in tenancy management from the start.

  • Always use a written tenancy agreement: this should clearly outline all terms, including rent, deposit, duration of tenancy, and both parties' responsibilities.
  • Keep detailed records: maintain meticulous records of all transactions and communications with your tenants. This includes rent payments, requests for repairs, complaints, and any other interactions.
  • Regular property inspections: conduct regular inspections of the property to ensure it is being well-maintained and to identify any issues early on. Always provide proper notice before inspections, respecting your tenants' privacy and rights.
  • Understand your legal obligations: stay informed about your legal responsibilities as a landlord, including those related to property safety, repairs, and tenant evictions.
  • Foster good landlord-tenant relationships: a positive relationship with your tenants can lead to a more harmonious tenancy and can make it easier to resolve any issues that may arise.

By following these best practices, landlords can significantly reduce the risk of complicated eviction processes and ensure a smoother, more positive tenancy experience for both parties.

If you find yourself navigating an eviction and you have no tenancy agreement to refer to, seek expert advice as soon as possible. AST Assistance can help you to understand your situation and guide you through the eviction process. To learn more, simply call us today on 01706 619954 or submit a contact form and we will be in touch at a time that best suits you.

Information, help & advice

Visit our Facebook and LinkedIn pages